Star Trek Discovery: A Critical Review
Hey Trekkies! Let's dive deep into Star Trek Discovery. Some love it, some... not so much. Here’s a detailed look at what makes this series stand out, and where it might have missed the mark.
Overview of Star Trek Discovery
Star Trek Discovery boldly goes where no Star Trek has gone before – or does it? Premiering in 2017, it marked the return of Star Trek to television after a long hiatus. Set roughly a decade before the original series (The Original Series, or TOS), Discovery tells the story of Michael Burnham, a human raised on Vulcan, and her journey through the ranks of Starfleet during a time of war with the Klingons. From the get-go, Discovery aimed to be different, bringing a modern sensibility to the Star Trek universe. This included serialized storytelling, complex character arcs, and high-definition visuals that made the classic Enterprise look like a relic of the past. The initial seasons focused heavily on the war with the Klingons, introducing new takes on familiar alien species and exploring themes of identity, loyalty, and redemption. One of the most significant departures was the emphasis on a central protagonist with a deeply flawed past, a stark contrast to the more episodic and morally clear-cut narratives of previous Star Trek series.
Discovery also distinguished itself with its visual style and production quality. The sets, costumes, and special effects were a significant upgrade, creating a visually stunning universe that felt both familiar and refreshingly new. The series embraced modern television trends, incorporating elements of action, suspense, and drama to create a more immersive and engaging viewing experience. However, these changes also sparked debate among long-time Star Trek fans, with some questioning whether Discovery had strayed too far from the core values and principles of the franchise. Despite the controversies, Star Trek Discovery successfully revitalized the Star Trek franchise, paving the way for other new series like Picard and Strange New Worlds. Its willingness to take risks and explore new narrative territory has ensured its place in Star Trek history, sparking conversations and debates that continue to shape the future of the franchise.
What Discovery Got Right
Okay, let’s give credit where it’s due. Discovery definitely brought some fresh and exciting elements to the Star Trek universe. The character development, for one, was top-notch. Michael Burnham, played by Sonequa Martin-Green, is a complex and compelling protagonist. Unlike the ever-perfect Captain Kirk or the stoic Spock, Burnham is flawed, makes mistakes, and evolves throughout the series. Her journey from mutineer to trusted Starfleet officer is a captivating arc that keeps you hooked. The supporting cast is equally strong. Characters like Saru, the Kelpien first officer, and Paul Stamets, the brilliant but socially awkward astromycologist, add depth and diversity to the crew. Their personal struggles and relationships are explored in detail, making them feel like real, relatable individuals. The diverse representation in Discovery is also commendable. The series features a wide range of ethnicities, genders, and sexual orientations, reflecting a more inclusive vision of the future. This commitment to diversity not only enriches the storytelling but also aligns with the core values of Star Trek, which has always championed tolerance and understanding.
Visually, Discovery is stunning. The updated Klingon designs, the sleek Starfleet ships, and the breathtaking alien landscapes are a feast for the eyes. The special effects are on par with big-budget movies, creating a cinematic experience that elevates the series above typical television fare. The show’s willingness to take risks with its storytelling is another strength. Discovery isn’t afraid to tackle complex themes and explore controversial topics. From the moral dilemmas of war to the challenges of identity and belonging, the series delves into weighty issues that resonate with contemporary audiences. The serialized format allows for more in-depth exploration of these themes, creating a richer and more nuanced narrative. Star Trek Discovery successfully modernized the franchise, appealing to a new generation of viewers while still honoring the spirit of the original series. Its strong characters, stunning visuals, and willingness to take risks make it a valuable addition to the Star Trek canon, ensuring its place in the hearts of Trekkies for years to come.
Where Discovery Falls Short
Now, let’s talk about the downsides. One of the biggest criticisms of Discovery is its departure from the optimistic and utopian vision of the future that Star Trek is known for. The original series presented a future where humanity had overcome its petty squabbles and united to explore the universe in peace. Discovery, on the other hand, portrays a darker and more conflicted future, with war, political intrigue, and moral compromises. While some argue that this reflects a more realistic portrayal of humanity, others feel that it betrays the core values of Star Trek. Another common complaint is the show's reliance on action and spectacle over thoughtful storytelling. Discovery often feels more like a space opera than a traditional Star Trek series, with constant explosions, battles, and high-stakes drama. While the action can be exciting, it sometimes comes at the expense of character development and philosophical exploration. The plot twists and retcons in Discovery can also be frustrating. The series has a habit of introducing major plot points that contradict established Star Trek lore or feel contrived and unnecessary. This can undermine the sense of continuity and immersion, making it difficult for long-time fans to fully embrace the show.
Furthermore, the tone of Discovery can be inconsistent. The series often struggles to balance its darker, more serious elements with the humor and optimism that are also hallmarks of Star Trek. This can result in jarring shifts in tone that feel out of place. For example, a lighthearted scene might be followed by a graphic depiction of violence, creating a sense of unease. The series' focus on Michael Burnham as the central protagonist has also drawn criticism. While Burnham is a compelling character, some feel that the show revolves too much around her, sidelining other potentially interesting characters and plotlines. This can make the Star Trek universe feel smaller and less diverse, as if everything is ultimately connected to Burnham's personal journey. Star Trek Discovery, while visually stunning and ambitious, has its flaws. Its departure from the optimistic vision of Star Trek, reliance on action over thoughtful storytelling, and inconsistent tone can be off-putting to some viewers. Despite its strengths, these shortcomings prevent it from reaching its full potential, leaving some fans feeling disappointed.
Fan Reception and Controversy
Ah, the fans. You can't please everyone, right? Discovery definitely stirred up a hornet's nest of opinions. Some fans embraced the new direction, praising its modern sensibilities and diverse cast. They appreciated the serialized storytelling and the deeper exploration of character arcs. Others, however, were not so thrilled. The most common criticisms included the darker tone, the deviation from Star Trek canon, and the emphasis on action over philosophical exploration. Some fans felt that Discovery had lost sight of what made Star Trek special, sacrificing its optimistic vision of the future for the sake of drama and spectacle. The redesigned Klingons also proved to be a major point of contention. Some fans felt that the new Klingon look was too different from the original design, making them unrecognizable. Others argued that it was a necessary update to reflect the changing times and the show's overall aesthetic. The debate over the Klingons raged online for months, with fans passionately defending their respective positions. The controversy surrounding Discovery highlights the challenges of revitalizing a beloved franchise. While it's important to stay true to the core values of the original series, it's also necessary to evolve and adapt to changing tastes. Discovery attempted to strike a balance between these two competing forces, but it didn't always succeed. The show's divisive reception serves as a reminder that Star Trek fans are a passionate and opinionated bunch, and that any attempt to reimagine the franchise will be met with both praise and criticism.
Ultimately, Star Trek Discovery is a series that sparks debate and elicits strong reactions. Its willingness to take risks and challenge conventions has earned it both praise and condemnation, solidifying its place in Star Trek history as a polarizing but ultimately significant addition to the franchise.
Final Verdict
So, is Star Trek Discovery worth watching? That depends. If you're a die-hard Trek purist who can't stand any deviation from the original formula, you might want to steer clear. But if you're open to a fresh take on the Star Trek universe, with complex characters, stunning visuals, and a willingness to explore darker themes, you might find something to enjoy. Discovery is not perfect, but it is ambitious and engaging. It's a show that will make you think, make you feel, and maybe even make you question everything you thought you knew about Star Trek. Whether you love it or hate it, there's no denying that Star Trek Discovery has left its mark on the franchise. And who knows? Maybe in a few years, we'll look back on it as a bold and innovative chapter in the Star Trek saga. So, buckle up, set your phasers to stun, and prepare for a Star Trek experience unlike any other. Whether you're a seasoned Trekkie or a newcomer to the Star Trek universe, Discovery offers a unique and compelling journey that is sure to spark your imagination and leave you wanting more. Just remember to keep an open mind and be prepared for a few surprises along the way.
